Can I go to Vermont in winter?+
Yes, and for silence it is arguably the best season. The honest part: January mornings can sit below zero Fahrenheit, daylight runs about nine hours, and driving after a storm needs winter tyres and patience. In exchange you get half prices, empty trails, snowshoeing, wood stoves and a stillness that simply does not exist in October. Choose a place with indoor space you would be happy in for a whole grey afternoon.
Is foliage season worth the crowds and the prices?+
Once, probably yes, because photographs undersell it. After that, most people quietly prefer the week just before peak or the week just after, when the colour is still good, roads are drivable and a room costs half as much. Peak fortnight means full car parks at every scenic pull off and restaurants needing reservations, which is a strange fit for a quiet week.
What actually happens during mud season?+
From late March through April the frozen ground thaws from the top down, so meltwater cannot drain and unpaved roads turn into deep churned mud. Hiking trails are closed in many places to stop erosion, the landscape is brown, and a fair number of small businesses take their annual break. It is the cheapest and emptiest time to come, which suits some people perfectly, as long as nobody was expecting to walk in the hills.